Bay Ridge Pizzeria

I'm beginning to crave this pizza weekly. Third order and consistently good. Crust is perfectly done, I usually like to dip the crusts, but no need with this crust. Cheese is salty and flavorful. The sauce has a slight sweetness, which I'm not usually a fan of, but this is just right, not overdone at all. Quality ingredients = Yum! Delivery is prompt to boot, and speaking to them on the phone is pleasant and easy (which is seemingly harder and harder to find these days).

Baked clams awesome as always. The buffalo wings weren't crispy and not enough spice, but the flavor was good. Tortellini alfredo was super saucy and a bit overcooked, but expected that for delivery. It was very good and I had more than enough left over for lunch today.

Although this particular order took 2 hours they still deserve a good review bc it's not common. One of my top pizza places to order from in Bay ridge, though I was disappointed with the Buffalo chicken pizza (tried something new). It was terrible :(

First time I ordered and no regrets! Clam Pie was so good... like stupid good. Worth the price and the staff is really sweet. I didn't say if I wanted red or white sauce, so they called and we're so helpful! Anyhow... YUM!

This restaurant has some of the best penne alla vodka I had in a long time. When I called to check on the status of my order, the staff was extremely helpful and professional. Will order here again. Definitely worth it!

This time we got the gluten-free pasta with vodka sauce and we asked for fewer croutons with the Caesar salad because we are mostly gluten-free. The food came promptly and the pasta was delicious. I think it is a mixture of corn and rice but you would really never know, it looks like regular ziti. The sauce was to die for. I pretty much licked my plate, it was so good. Warning-if you have leftovers (unlikely), warm a short amount of time in the microwave as the texture will change a little. Delicious, will get it again.

I just found my favorite pizza place in Bay Ridge. Not only is this place delicious but the pizza arrived oven hot and within a reasonable amount of time, too. You can taste the quality in the sauce and cheese used in their pizzas. When I ordered the garlic knots, I was expecting the typical knots found at almost every other pizza place, but instead fresh garlic knots arrived that were made to order. I have already saved this as one of my favorite Seamless restaurants. Thank you for making my day!

Food was great as usual, there was just one small issue. On the restaurant's menu, the 6 piece mozzarella sticks were showing that they cost 65 dollars. Now, I have ordered the mozzarella sticks in the past (Highly reccomend them as well) and I know that price is incorrect. This is most likely of no fault to the people at Bay Ridge Pizzeria but I just thought I'd give a heads up in case they weren't aware of it.

I order the panini for my Mom and she loves it every time she takes a bite it's OMG this is delicious :) lol The Salad is one of my all time favorites, but I just know if i ever decide to make it it won't come out as good as who ever is making it at Bay Ridge Pizza. Who would of thought a salad from a pizza place. It's delicious TRUST me it's so good.

We consistently order from here. Their food is delicious and my husband is addicted to their penne vodka with grilled chicken. Such a great surprise coming from a pizzeria. Thats actually the one thing we havent tried yet, their Pizza.. lol.. but Im sure its as delicious as everything else.